White Rock Associates, L.L.C.

Investment Banking

  • Home
  • Strategic Partners
    • Chapman, Hext & Co., P.C
    • CH Wealth Management, L.L.C.
    • White Rock Venture Fund, L.P.
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Our Ranking
    • Mission Statement
    • Industries
  • Ideas & Options
  • Transactions
  • Our Services
    • Capital Markets
    • Mergers and Acquisitions
      • Buyside & Sellside Transactions
      • Leveraged Transactions
    • Advisory Services
    • Restructuring/Turnaround
  • Contact
  • Login
    • Dataroom
    • Webmail
You are here: Home / Ideas and Options / The Pension Fund Crisis and Private Equity

The Pension Fund Crisis and Private Equity

March 5, 2018 by admin

Recently I had the opportunity to be a speaker at Aspire.  Aspire (http://www.chapmanhext.com/dallas-leadership-events-aspire/) is a speaker series hosted by our affiliate Chapman Hext & Co. P.C.

As part of my speech I briefly touched on the amount of excess capital available in the alternative assets space.  In this case alternative assets are primarily made up of investments in hedge funds and private equity funds.  As I mentioned in my presentation, in 2015 private equity had a record $1.3 trillion in “dry powder”, which is industry lingo for available money to invest.  This dry powder inherently creates competition between funds to invest or buy solid companies.  In essence there becomes four to five qualified buyers for every one private company looking to sell.  As you can imagine with this war chest of cash and competition between funds, purchase price multiples have gone up to historic levels.  The question then becomes, where did this money come from, and will it last?

A significant amount of the dry powder has come from pension funds.  As you can see from the chart below, the percentage of pension fund’s portfolio in alternative assets has doubled since 2008, going from 9% of the overall assets to 18% of the overall assets.

http://publicplansdata.org/quick-facts/national/

Why has this portion of the overall holdings doubled in just 8 years?  It’s a combination of decades of low government contributions, investment underperformance (interest rates at nearly zero) and growing obligations to the beneficiaries of the pension fund.  Sprinkle in a recession or two and you can see why the investment boards of these large pension funds are looking at a scenario where the assets are growing slower than the liabilities coming due.  Estimates of this short fall, or unfunded liabilities, range from $1.6 trillion to $4 trillion.

The solution, invest in riskier non liquid investments that promise a higher return.  According to the Public Plans database, a decade ago alternative assets represented 7% of the holdings at the biggest 150 US pension funds; in 2016 alternative assets make up 26% of the holdings.

Has it worked?  Well many economists are starting to sound the alarm bells, that no in fact it has not worked and we are in for a world of trouble.  A prime example is the crisis brewing at CalPERS.  CalPERS is the California Public Employee’s Retirement System which manages pension and health benefits for more than 1.6 million public employees in California.  Recently Steve Westly, former California controller and CalPERS board member, stated “The pension crisis is inching closer by the day.  CalPERS just voted to increase the amount cities must pay to the agency.  Cities point to possible insolvency if payments keep rising but CalPERS is near insolvency itself.  It may be a reform or bailout soon.”

Although CalPERS may be the largest US public pension fund, they are not alone.  According to Danielle DiMartino Booth, total unfunded liabilities in state and local pensions have grown 5x in the last decade.  According to a 2014 Pew study, only 15 states follow policies that have funded at least 100% of their pension needs.

So what’s next?  California, Kentucky, Texas have all made moves to reduce the assumed rate of return in their actuarial calculations.  That doesn’t change the amount coming due to beneficiaries of these funds, and so local governments can expect pension costs to jump some 50-60% in the coming years.  In Dallas for instance, four years ago the local pension reported being 100% funded.  As we have all read in the news, turns out these risky real estate investments didn’t turn out and thus the fire and police pension fund borders on insolvency.  The realistic solution, double the municipal tax rate.  Not a very popular or easy thing to do, but all solutions are bad ones at this point.

What we do know is the music will stop eventually.  Be it through Federal government intervention and a tax payer bailout or some other means.  It is safe to say that the dry powder, and the allocation to risky non liquid investments won’t be in the cards when big brother takes over.  And so, as the war chests are emptied and private equity starves for fresh cash, will they continue to pay up to purchase or invest in private businesses?  My guess is no.

If you have any questions on the above, or want to discuss your specific situation, please feel free to reach out to us at 972-644-7111 or email smartin@whiterockadvisors.com.

Filed Under: Ideas and Options

Contact:

WHITE ROCK ADVISORS, LLC
5001 Spring Valley Road, Suite 850W
Dallas, TX 75244
972.644.7111
www.whiterockadvisors.com

Simon Martin
972.644.7111 Ext. 337
smartin@whiterockadvisors.com

Ideas & Options

The Pension Fund Crisis and Private Equity

Simon Martin Announced as Winner of the 8th Annual Emerging Leaders Award

It’s Not All About the Rolodex

Welcome to White Rock Associates

White Rock Advisors, LLC is now White Rock Associates, LLC (“WRA”).  Recently the Securities and Exchange Commission adopted a new rule under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, establishing a standard of conduct for broker-dealers (“Regulation Best Interest”).  Among other rule changes, Regulation Best Interest set forth that the use of the term ‘advisor’ in a name by a broker-dealer that is not also a registered investment adviser is prohibited.  WRA specializes in mergers and acquisitions and corporate finance for privately held businesses.  WRA does not provide investment advice to individual retail customers.  As such WRA is not a registered investment advisor and therefore had to … Read More

Bringing Clients Expertise, Knowledge, and Financial Resources

The Directors of White Rock Associates know that, in today’s customer driven economy, companies need expert business advice and financial resources to grow and compete in a rapidly changing marketplace.  Through our extensive network of capital providers, we are able to bring people and capital … Read More

Financial Reporting

If you would you like to know more about financial reporting, please visit our Chapman, Hext & CO website.

Visit the Site

Taxation

If you would you like to know more about taxation, please visit our Chapman, Hext & CO website.

Visit the Site

Wealth Management

If you would you like to know more about wealth management, please visit our CH Wealth website.

Visit the Site

Copyright© 2021 | White Rock Associates, L.L.C | Providence Towers | 5001 Spring Valley Rd., Ste. 850W | Dallas TX, 75244 | TEL: (972) 644-7111 FAX: (972) 680-8685

White Rock Associates, LLC (“White Rock”) member FINRA/SIPC is a limited purpose broker dealer that provides a limited range of brokerage and financial advisory services. White Rock does not hold customer accounts, funds or securities, accept trading orders, engage in proprietary trading or market making. White Rock is engaged solely in advising companies and private equity funds on capital raising, mergers and acquisitions, and corporate restructuring. This is not an offer or solicitation for brokerage services, investment advisory services, or other products or services in any jurisdiction where we are not authorized to do business or where such offer or solicitation would be contrary to the securities laws or other local laws and regulations of that jurisdiction.

This site is designed solely for U.S. residents. Non-U.S. residents are subject to country-specific restrictions.